Olive Oil, Balsamic Vinegar & Gift Sets for Sale

Olive Oil, Balsamic Vinegar & Gift Sets for Sale

Hand-harvested from our family's Koroneiki groves and cold-pressed within hours for exceptional purity. With 0.2–0.4% acidity (up to five times lower than the extra virgin olive oil standard), this is olive oil the way it's meant to taste.

Browse our collection of extra virgin olive oil, infused olive oils, balsamic vinegars, gift sets, pantry products, and merchandise to find authentic flavors for your kitchen or the perfect gift for someone special.

Prefer to shop in person? Visit us at Findlay Market, 1801 Race Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202, or at our Montgomery Store & Infusion Kitchen, 8210 Market Place Lane, Cincinnati, OH 45242, where you can purchase our products and explore our selection firsthand.

 

Skip to results list
SHOP

Filter

  • Kofinas Extra Virgin Olive Oil in a tall green glass bottle with a gold label and mountain logo
    BEST SELLER

    Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Crete

    Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Crete
    $17.00

    Buy Extra Virgin Olive Oil cold pressed from our single source family estate in Crete. Enjoy generations of tradition with authentic Greek EVOO. Shop Kofinas!

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Certified Organic extra virgin olive oil in a tall green glass bottle with a gold label

    Certified Organic Olive Oil

    Certified Organic Olive Oil
    $28.00

    Kofinas’s all-natural, pure extra virgin olive oil begins with olives hand gathered at their peak for maximum flavor. This has been certified organic by the European Union, with the code number GR-BIO-06 and the place of farming Crete, Greece. Shop now!
  • Kofinas Butter infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle beside curls of butter

    Butter Infused

    Butter Infused
    $17.00

    Butter flavor infused in monovarietal Koroneiki EVOO from Crete's Messara Valley. Rich, creamy taste with significantly less saturated fat than dairy butter.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Basil infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with fresh basil leaves

    Basil Infused

    Basil Infused
    $17.00

    Dried basil infused in single origin monovarietal Koroneiki EVOO from Crete's Messara Valley. Grassy, earthy notes for drizzling, salads & pasta. Shop now.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Dill infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with a fresh dill sprig

    Dill Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil

    Dill Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil
    $17.00

    Real dried dill infused in single origin Koroneiki EVOO from Crete's Messara Valley. Bright, herby flavor for seafood, potatoes & vegetables. Shop today.

     SELECT SIZE

  • Curated Gift Sets for Every Occasion

    Beautifully packaged sets for housewarmings, holidays, and anyone who appreciates quality. Ships gift-ready.

    Shop BEST SELLING GiftS
    olive oil gift set by Kofinas
  • Kofinas Mediterranean Herb infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with dried herbs
    BEST SELLER

    Mediterranean Herb Infused

    Mediterranean Herb Infused
    $17.00

    We use a mix of real rosemary, basil, thyme and oregano to give our olive oil the hardy…

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Garlic infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with a garlic bulb on herbs
    BEST SELLER

    Garlic Infused

    Garlic Infused
    $17.00

    Real garlic, rosemary, thyme & basil infused in single origin Koroneiki EVOO from the Messara Valley. 500mg/kg+ polyphenols, 0.2–0.3% acidity. Order now.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Chipotle infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with a red chipotle pepper

    Chipotle Infused

    Chipotle Infused
    $17.00

    Chipotle chili peppers, basil, thyme & bay leaf in single origin Koroneiki EVOO from the Messara Valley. Smoky, bold heat for dipping & grilling. Order now.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Spicy Garlic infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with red chili and garlic
    BEST SELLER

    Spicy Garlic Infused

    Spicy Garlic Infused
    $17.00

    Our spicy garlic infused olive oil is created by using two of our most popular flavors.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Wild Orange infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with fresh orange slices

    Wild Orange Infused Olive Oil

    Wild Orange Infused Olive Oil
    $17.00

    Wild orange infused in monovarietal Koroneiki EVOO from Crete's Messara Valley. Sweet citrus warmth for salads, baked goods & marinades. Order from Kofinas.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Kofinas Lime Cilantro infused extra virgin olive oil in a green glass bottle with lime and cilantro

    Lime Cilantro Infused

    Lime Cilantro Infused
    $17.00

    Lime cilantro infused in single origin monovarietal Koroneiki EVOO from Crete's Messara Valley. 500mg/kg+ polyphenols. Bright citrus flavor. Shop now.

     SELECT SIZE
  • Black bottle of Greek balsamic vinegar with strawberry, with a strawberry on the label

    Strawberry Greek Balsamic Vinegar

    Strawberry Greek Balsamic Vinegar
    $14.00

    Ripe strawberry blended with aged Greek dark balsamic imported from Greece. Fruity, tangy & bright for desserts, salads & glazed proteins. Order from Kofinas.
  • Burgundy organza gift bag holding two Kofinas olive oil bottles

    Two Bottle Sampler Gift Set

    Two Bottle Sampler Gift Set
    $18.00

    Choose any two flavors—olive oil or vinegar—to create your own mini sampler pack.
  • Sheer organza gift bag holding three Kofinas olive oil bottles
    Sale

    Three Bottle Sampler Gift Set

    Three Bottle Sampler Gift Set
    $26.00 $27.00

    Choose any three flavors—olive oil or vinegar—to create your own mini sampler pack.
  • Olive-green jute gift tote with rope handles holding Kofinas olive oil bottles
    Sale

    Four Bottle Gift Set

    Four Bottle Gift Set
    $36.00 $37.00

    When we have so many flavors, why choose just one?
  • Red jute gift tote with rope handles holding six Kofinas olive oil bottles
    Sale

    Six Bottle Sampler Gift Set

    Six Bottle Sampler Gift Set
    $47.00 $54.00

    When we have so many great flavors, why choose just a few?
  • Tall dark bottle of Kofinas Saba Petimezi grape must reduction with a purple label
    Sold out

    Petimezi Traditional Grape Must Syrup

    Petimezi Traditional Grape Must Syrup
    $17.00

    Italian grape must syrup made from cooked-down grape juice. A natural alternative sweetener for drizzling over yogurt, ice cream, baked goods & more. Shop now.
  • Clear pouch of Mt. Kofinas Seasonings dried herb and spice blend with a yellow label

    Olive Oil Dipping Spice Pack

    Olive Oil Dipping Spice Pack
    $6.00

    Elevate your olive oil experience with this curated dipping spice collection, designed…
  • Amber glass jar of Cretan thyme honey with a Greek label and dark lid

    Cretan Thyme Honey: Raw & Pure

    Cretan Thyme Honey: Raw & Pure
    $8.00

    Indulge in raw Cretan Thyme Honey. Harvested from wild thyme flowers for a unique, aromatic sweetness. Healthy, pure, & delicious. Order your jar today!
  • Jar of mild Olive Muffalata olive spread with a yellow lid and colorful label

    Muffalata Mild

    Muffalata Mild
    $15.00

    Smooth, savory, and packed with briny olive goodness.
  • Jar of Classic Olive Muffalata olive spread with a silver lid and colorful label

    Olive Muffalata: Savory Spread

    Olive Muffalata: Savory Spread
    $15.00

    Enhance your meals with Olive Muffalata. A savory mix of olives, veggies, & spices. Perfect for sandwiches or antipasto platters. Taste the bold mix!
  • Jar of Spicy Olive Muffalata olive spread with a red lid and colorful label

    Muffalata Spicy

    Muffalata Spicy
    $15.00

    A bold, fiery fusion of premium olives and garden-fresh vegetables, marinated in a bold…
  • Kraft paper gift bag with rope handles holding two Kofinas olive oil bottles and a hang tag
    Sale

    Two Full Size Bottle (Mix/Match) Gift Bag Set

    Two Full Size Bottle (Mix/Match) Gift Bag Set
    $48.00 $49.00

    Create your own two full-size bottle set with any combination of olive oils and vinegars.
  • Kraft gift box with Kofinas olive oil, a seasonings pouch and a patterned dipping plate

    Mediterraean Dipping Gift Set

    Mediterraean Dipping Gift Set
    $35.00

    Mediterranean spice blend crafted for dipping with Koroneiki EVOO. Herbaceous, bold flavor—pair with crusty bread for an authentic Greek experience. Order now.

Trusted by Thousands of Home Cooks

Don't just take our word for it, see why families across America choose Kofinas for authentic Greek flavor.

Just found this business here in Cinci so went over and dropped in the store today.  Nick was right there, totally enthusiastic to talk about the quality products and offered me a sample of the extra-virgin oil from a freshly opened bottle.  I found the quality to be exceptional, even better than artisanal oil one can find in the rural Peloponnese.  How fortunate we locals are to have this so close at hand!

~ Bill Mulert

I discovered this olive oil several years algo while visiting a friend in Covington, KY.  For years, I have made her buy it for me and ship it to me (or picked it up when I’ve visited again).  I live in Atlanta, Georgia and am overjoyed that I can now order it online!  The best avocado is toast is avocado mixed with Citrus Infused Olive Oil and some salt!  I also use it sauteing vegetables.

~ Meredith Burke Hammons

So impressed with Kofinas! I found a balsamic vinegar while I was in Greece and assumed once I returned to the states that I’d never have it again. I searched online and Kofinas had it in stock. I ordered a case and it was shipped out in less than a day! Their prompt service and great selection are amazing! Thank you!!!

~ Katie Gaddy

Most Asked Questions

READ ALL FAQ
Should I store my olive oil in the refrigerator so that it lasts longer?

This is not at all necessary. A dark place without moisture is the optimal location to store your oil. Keep your extra bottles of Mt. Kofinas olive oil in a cool, dark place like a pantry closet. Sunlight and moisture are two things that can harm your olive oil. However, olive oil can be used as a natural preservative. By its nature, olive oil is fairly stable and certainly is delicious for many years.
 I forgot my olive oil in my freezing car overnight and now the olive oil is cloudy white. Did my olive oil spoil?

No, it just turned to a solid. After being in room temperature for a while it will return to it’s original state. Trust us, it will still taste great.
There’s pulp at the bottom of my olive oil, does this mean that it went bad?

No, our olive oil is natural and unfiltered so with time the fruit particles may settle. Mix the oil by tipping the bottle before using so it is evenly dispersed.
Can I cook with the olive oil?

Yes, people have been cooking with olive oil for thousands of years. As part of the Mediterranean diet this is the main ingredient and cooking method of most dishes. It also gives a great taste to the food and helps infuse flavors.
Can I fry with olive oil?

Yes, it is actually a great oil to use because it stands up well since the smoking temperature (380˚F – 400˚F) is above the ideal frying temperature (350˚F-365˚F). The reason olive oil is not commonly used in frying is based on cost. Out of the available oils, olive oil is among the most expensive, but also the most delicious.
If I fry with olive oil, will the olive oil change from a “good fat” to a “bad fat” ?

Extra virgin olive oil is a great source of poly-unsaturated fats. Simply frying with olive oil will not change the chemical composition. Your extra virgin olive oil will NOT change into a saturated fat, or a trans fat.